« Shedding a little less light on the situationSing a song for six-packs »

See Bob run

June 3, 2009

Posted by: Jason Email , at 12:38:45 pm
Category: General

See Bob run

I'd like to guide you through a thought experiment to test your imagination. Read through the following passage, then close your eyes to picture the scene. Then click on the link to answer some questions. Simple, right? We'll let's proceed...

Bob is leaving work, the lucky devil, and walks outside of the office to find an overcast and generally miserable day. As he strolls out to his car, a light drizzle begins to fall and Bob picks up his pace. The rain starts to fall even harder, which again prompts Bob to begin a trot for his vehicle. As the falling water transitions to a downright pour, Bob starts running for his car, popping the trunk as he gets close to pull out an umbrella. Upon reaching his car, Bob pulls out the umbrella and opens it in preparation for walking to the driver's side door. But just as the umbrella snaps open, the rain stops and the sun peeks from behind the clouds.

Now that you've considered the scenario, there is a very important question...

Follow up:

What color is the umbrella? Was it a typical black or perhaps a fancy and garish color such as red or yellow? Was it even a solid color or did it feature a pattern such as stripes or polka dots?

You may realize now that there are no incorrect answers; the color of the umbrella is determined solely by what you pictured as you recounted the story in your mind. What is the purpose of this exercise? Solely to put the next statement in some form of context.

I can't see the damn umbrella. I don't see the car or the rain either. I have know idea of what Bob should look like. I just can't seem to form a mental image.

Apparently this isn't unheard of, but I don't have any idea of how common it is. The topic of mental imagery is one, from what little Internet searching I've done on the matter, that seems to have gained a bit of prominence in the last three decades. But almost all of the attention seems to be diverted towards how the brain formulates a mental image, not why some people can have a total lack of them.

There also appear to be some tests, such as the VVIQ, that determine a person's faculty for producing a vivid mental image. So at least it has been recognized that it is a variable trait or skill. But if I took the VVIQ, I'd have the worst possible score, reporting, "No image at all, you only 'know' that you are thinking of an object," for every question.

If you have read this far, please oblige me and answer the question with as much detail as you wish to provide using the comments link below. We probably won't solve anything, but maybe I'll find out if a couple more of you broke your projectors, too.

4 comments

Comment from: Josh [Visitor]
I pictured the umbrella black, because presumably Bob is a dude. And no self-respecting businessman with a tan trenchcoat would buy a brightly colored umbrella.

I have also come to the conclusion that Bob is an idiot. First of all, he strolled out to his car. Who strolls nowadays? Second, who would open the trunk in a downpour to get out an umbrella, just for those last few seconds before you get in the car? This does not make sense! Chewbacca is a Wookie!
06/04/09 @ 07:32
Comment from: Jason [Member] Email
Maybe he is getting it out of his trunk to use later. But more likely is that he drives an extreme stretch limo, and his door is at least a quarter mile from his trunk.
06/08/09 @ 08:48
Comment from: Phil [Visitor]
I think that your mind just attaches whatever is simple to the details that your not focusing on. Since the focus of the story seems to be Bob, his ever increasing pace and the rain, that's what I focused on. I could "see" the quickening rain and Bob increasing his pace. In my mind, I didn't really see anything more than his lower body up to about his thighs and the rain drops hitting the ground. So, when he pulled out the umbrella, it was black. The story hadn't pulled my mind into that direction. An example of what I mean is that if story has started to talk what kind of umbrella he had before he opened it, then I would have "seen" that instead.
06/08/09 @ 10:10
Comment from: Peter [Visitor]
I need to check out your main site more often, you put up some interesting stuff. I didn't read it carefully enough to get a complete mental picture, and I didn't really picture the umbrella, just a guys legs running in the rain. Emily said that the umbrella was black. Emily says that she visualizes just about everything.

Poincare had to visualize his lectures that he listened to because his eyesight was so bad. Euler was able to visualize everything even after he went blind. In fact I can't think of a single great mathematician that couldn't visualize. You're going to be the first one.
08/27/09 @ 19:10

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

Account

Search

Links

XML Feeds

powered by b2evolution free blog software